Two centuries after George Medhurst first imagined moving people through vacuum tubes, India is proving that sometimes, the future takes longer to arrive than the hype suggests—but when it does, it’s worth the wait.
In 2013, Elon Musk introduced the Hyperloop Alpha concept, which is still available on Tesla’s website. Musk’s white paper reignited interest in this futuristic transportation mode, promising speeds exceeding 700 mph through low-pressure tubes powered by maglev (magnetic levitation) and solar energy. According to Musk’s vision, a Hyperloop trip from Washington, D.C., to New York would take less than 30 minutes, while a trip from D.C. to Baltimore would take under eight minutes. These promises seemed like the stuff of dreams—until reality set in, leaving believers in this ultra-fast “fifth mode” of transportation grappling with the immense challenges of making it a reality.
www.tesla.com“>
Global struggles: The Hyperloop dream meets reality
Hyperloop One, one of the most well-funded ventures, raised over $450 million and built test tracks in Nevada. However, despite conducting tests that reached speeds of up to 310 km/h (193 mph) on a 500-meter track, the company never came close to achieving the promised 1,220 km/h (760 mph) speeds. It ultimately shut down in December 2023, failing to reach commercial viability.The obstacles were numerous: maintaining near-vacuum conditions, ensuring passenger safety during extreme acceleration and deceleration, and overcoming prohibitively high infrastructure costs. Other companies, like Hyperloop TT, continue to pursue partnerships—including a joint venture in Italy and the Abu Dhabi-Dubai project—though financial instability remains a concern.
India’s new Hypetrain: A pragmatic approach
India’s approach to Hyperloop development represents a deliberate departure from the fragmented global landscape, but questions remain about its practicality and long-term viability.Unlike private-led initiatives elsewhere, India is developing Hyperloop technology through academic institutions like IIT Madras, which has constructed Asia’s longest Hyperloop test tube with government funding. The collaboration between the Research Designs and Standards Organisation (RDSO) and IIT Madras ensures clear accountability and knowledge transfer, which could accelerate development—if properly resourced.
However, the financial commitment, while significant domestically, pales in comparison to the billions required for full-scale implementation. The current funding of Rs 20.89 crore ($2.5 million) for the test facility is merely a drop in the ocean compared to the estimated $10-20 billion needed for a commercial Hyperloop network.
Strategic partnerships with institutions like the Technical University of Munich and companies like SYSTRA bring valuable expertise. However, while knowledge transfer is beneficial, over-reliance on foreign technical assistance could undermine India’s goal of Atmanirbhar Bharat (self-reliant India). The balance between collaboration and self-reliance remains delicate.
Also read: India advances hyperloop tech with IIT Madras, SYSTRA partnership
The solar angle: Sustainability vs infrastructure challenges
The sustainability narrative surrounding Hyperloop in India warrants closer examination, especially given Musk’s emphasis on renewable energy integration in his white paper. Indian Railways has made significant progress in solar energy adoption, and this existing infrastructure could support Hyperloop systems.
However, the massive infrastructure requirements for Hyperloop corridors could lead to large-scale land acquisition, potentially displacing communities and disrupting ecosystems. While solar integration is promising, implementing it at scale presents significant engineering challenges, including maintaining a consistent energy supply across long distances and varying weather conditions.
Hyperloop: A gamble or a breakthrough?
Ultimately, India’s Hyperloop strategy will be judged not just on technical success but on its ability to deliver social and environmental benefits without repeating the mistakes of other nations.
“Hyperloop is at a nascent stage,” Railways Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw acknowledged in a recent parliamentary reply. This candid admission underscores an important truth about innovation: not every ambitious project is destined for commercial success. Yet, some endeavors are pursued not just for their immediate practicality but for the advancement of knowledge itself.
The evolving Hyperloop landscape remains fascinating, with proponents passionately advocating for its potential while skeptics question its financial and environmental feasibility. For enthusiasts, it marks the dawn of a new transportation era; for critics, it’s a high-stakes gamble with uncertain returns.
And perhaps, just perhaps, in a decade or two, we might find ourselves whisked across the country at near-sonic speeds, transforming hours into minutes. The future of transportation may yet be rewritten—one vacuum-sealed tube at a time.
