A latest Fb publish from a longtime Beautycounter vendor reads a bit of like a celeb’s breakup announcement.

“I’ve some onerous information to share with you all,” she begins, occurring to say that she had realized the corporate was on hiatus and had briefly stopped promoting its “clear” serums and lotions. The publish was accompanied by a picture of her sitting in a hammock, which she described as a “happier time” with the model.

For a lot of of Beautycounter’s impartial salespeople, the sudden shutdown of the model earlier this month felt just like the painful finish to a relationship that had grown, to make use of a phrase they’re intimately aware of, poisonous.

Beautycounter was constructed round a multi-level advertising and marketing mannequin, the place sellers, which it calls consultants, earn commissions for gross sales they make, in addition to a minimize from income generated by anybody they recruit. These consultants numbered round 60,000 in 2021, when the Carlyle Group, a personal fairness agency, acquired the model at a $1 billion valuation. Impartial sellers continued to drive an amazing majority of income whilst Beautycounter opened its personal shops and landed area at huge magnificence retailers.

However even earlier than final month’s closure, Beautycounter’s vendor community had seen higher days. The ranks of consultants had dwindled by round a 3rd for the reason that acquisition, mentioned an individual aware of the matter. Some drifted off after Gregg Renfrew, who based the model in 2011 and galvanised hundreds of consultants on lobbying campaigns to manage magnificence components, stepped down as chief government on the finish of 2021.

Many others grew to become pissed off as they struggled to hit gross sales targets set by the corporate, which they wanted to clear to obtain insider reductions and money funds. Today, magnificence aisles are stocked with dozens of manufacturers that, like Beautycounter, declare to be “free from” sure chemical compounds and probably dangerous components. There was one more reason pals and coworkers have been much less receptive to pitches on Fb: as is the destiny of many MLMs, a major share of potential clients had develop into sellers themselves.

Consultants have been additionally dealing with maybe their stiffest competitors from an sudden supply: Beautycounter itself. The model had its personal e-commerce website, and had experimented with pop-ups in Sephora and Goal, plus shops in New York, Denver and Nantucket, Massachusetts. However a nationwide wholesale partnership with Ulta Magnificence, launched in February 2023, was a turning level, sellers say.

“It took the whole lot away from the consultants,” mentioned Christina Allen, a former salesperson in San Antonio, Texas. “It was going to be [in Ulta Beauty] completely, they made that clear, and there was no motive to then use a guide anymore.”

Renfrew’s return in February was a trigger for celebration amongst her followers. On April 18, the corporate introduced she was shopping for the model again, and that it will briefly halt direct gross sales forward of a Could 1 relaunch.

That date got here and went. On Could 6, Renfrew despatched an e-mail to Beautycounter consultants notifying them that the comeback can be postponed till late 2024, blaming the delay on points restoring operations, saying that her authentic timeline was “too aggressive.” Consultants wouldn’t have the ability to promote any merchandise within the meantime, successfully terminating their Beautycounter careers. Renfrew additionally warned that the corporate may look totally different when it reopened.

Renfrew is beloved amongst clear magnificence devotees – on social media, consultants nonetheless wax lyrical about their timeless perception in her mission – and she or he’s confirmed her grit earlier than. To hold the corporate via to its subsequent chapter, nonetheless, new methods that each help its loyal guide base and likewise open the aperture to wider international progress are wanted.

The longer Beautycounter takes to reopen, the more durable that balancing act turns into. When multi-level advertising and marketing firms cease rising, their intricate webs of impartial salespeople can shortly collapse because it turns into more durable for consultants to recoup start-up prices or recruit new members (Beautycounter consultants paid a $50 enrolment payment, and have been inspired to buy “starter units” costing as a lot as $735). The bond MLMs construct with their sellers also can develop into a legal responsibility. The corporate’s restoration will play out in public, with hundreds of emotionally invested consultants scrutinising each transfer.

“Beautycounter isn’t only a model to me,” one vendor wrote on Instagram concerning the closure. “It’s been a catalyst for private progress and advocacy.”

One other wrote: “I’m unhappy, heartbroken, nonetheless making an attempt to course of all of it.”

Clear Beginnings

Launched in 2013, Beautycounter performed a serious position in popularising the concept that individuals would purchase merchandise based mostly on what components they didn’t include.

The model’s “by no means” checklist eschewed greater than 2,800 components, from oxybenzone to phthalates. Renfrew appeared on Bloomberg and CNBC to advocate for clear magnificence. She additionally testified earlier than Congress about beauty reform.

“[Beautycounter] was a giant innovator,” mentioned Invoice Detwiler, managing associate in Fernbrook, which invested in Beautycounter in 2014 and once more in 2016. “It was actually the primary clear magnificence enterprise that spoke about non-toxic components.”

The merchandise themselves have been additionally interesting, profitable awards from Attract and Cosmopolitan. Allen mentioned she joined the gross sales programme after making an attempt a good friend’s cleaning balm and being impressed.

“Then, I discovered the foremost pitch level that you just get your individual low cost for those who select to develop into a guide, and that me,” she mentioned.

Beautycounter operated in some ways like different multi-level advertising and marketing firms, similar to Amway and Mary Kay, the place recruiting downlines was usually the quickest route to creating huge cash.

Consultants didn’t have to purchase stock, a controversial follow utilized by some MLMs that may saddle sellers with losses in the event that they fail to maneuver sufficient product.

As a substitute, consultants logged gross sales into an inside database, and Beautycounter would deal with stock and transport. Consultants needed to hit a minimal of $1,200 in gross sales each six months to stay enrolled (a determine diminished to $750 in 2022).

“I didn’t anticipate heaps out of it. I needed the low cost and I assumed perhaps I may get a number of individuals to buy underneath me,” mentioned Allen, who remembers having one individual in her downline, and making about $30 to $80 in commissions most months.

Even that took effort, although.

“You couldn’t simply publish [on social media] about one thing you appreciated right here and there. You needed to make a constant effort to publish day by day,” she mentioned.

There have been different perks for probably the most lively sellers: when Renfrew testified earlier than Congress, sellers accompanied her to fulfill with politicians.

The MLM construction, together with the lobbying campaigns, doubled as unpaid advertising and marketing, and cemented sellers’ loyalty, guaranteeing Beautycounter stayed on the forefront of the booming clear magnificence class even amid competitors from manufacturers similar to Goop, Tata Harper and Drunk Elephant. Gross sales surpassed $300 million in 2018.

There have been rising pains. MLMs should always battle attrition, as individuals realise how a lot work is required to earn commissions, and desires of constructing a self-sustaining enterprise soften away. Increasing too shortly may also be an issue. Consultants run out of recent clients if everybody within the model can also be promoting it.

That was a difficulty Allen mentioned she bumped into in rural Texas. She was unenrolled as a guide in early 2021 after failing to fulfill the minimal gross sales threshold. She rejoined later that yr, however dropped out once more in 2022.

Peak Clear

Beautycounter navigated these points adeptly for many of its first decade. The pandemic was a serious boon. Folks spent their days on social media, the place, unable to go to bodily shops, they have been now extra open to gross sales pitches from Beautycounter consultants. Hundreds of thousands of individuals misplaced or stop their jobs, and lots of tried their hand at multi-level advertising and marketing.

It was at that second, in 2021, that the Carlyle Group acquired a majority stake. On the time, the non-public fairness large appeared to have a magic contact with client manufacturers, having efficiently flipped the streetwear label Supreme and sneaker model Golden Goose.

The decline at Beautycounter set in nearly instantly after the acquisition, the supply aware of the corporate’s interior workings throughout that interval informed The Enterprise of Magnificence. Like many manufacturers that benefitted from pandemic tendencies, Beautycounter’s gross sales suffered because the world opened up once more. Rising wages and plentiful job openings made Beautycounter’s proposition to consultants much less interesting.

Together with Renfrew, a number of longtime senior executives, together with the chief monetary officer and head of mission, exited in early 2022. In April 2022, Beautycounter revamped consultants’ compensation construction, limiting commissions from downlines by eradicating commissions from private orders, adjustments aimed toward incentivising recruitment of recent clients. The tweaks have been anticipated to chop earnings for prime sellers by 20 to 29 %, however some consultants who had a whole lot of individuals of their downlines noticed their returns slashed by 60 %, sellers alleged in a lawsuit filed in US federal court docket in January 2024. Plaintiffs, one among whom was reported to have earned over $1 million between 2014 and 2023, mentioned they have been terminated from Beautycounter after trying to recoup misplaced earnings by becoming a member of a second MLM.

By 2022, the model had swung from an annual revenue to working at a loss, in accordance the identical particular person. Marc Rey, who succeeded Renfrew as CEO, departed in June 2023.

‘Win November’

After the acquisition, Allen remembers heavy promotional exercise and a sooner launch cadence aimed toward reengaging consultants and their clients. However the model was additionally starting to maneuver away from relying as closely on its direct sellers.

The supply near the enterprise informed The Enterprise of Magnificence there was an inside marketing campaign in late 2021 to attempt to “win November” and drive extra gross sales through e-commerce and use it as a lever to develop model consciousness. The initiative fell wanting targets.

In February 2023, Beautycounter entered Ulta Magnificence. Ulta declined to remark, however sources near Beautycounter mentioned it has carried out nicely there. Even now whereas the model’s direct gross sales are dormant, it’s nonetheless accessible in Ulta shops and the retailer’s web site.

The adjustments stored coming. In line with a former Beautycounter worker, Carlyle applied two restructuring plans in 2023, representing a major lack of personnel. Along with Rey’s exit, the pinnacle of the provision chain and the chief impression officer have been let go, amongst different roles, mentioned the previous worker.

In a press release to The Enterprise of Magnificence, a Carlyle spokesperson mentioned Beautycounter skilled “important market and channel headwinds” and that its efforts to help the model together with elevated spend on advertising and marketing and product improvement didn’t cease the enterprise from shedding floor.

Morale suffered, mentioned the previous worker, however even then there have been plans for additional enlargement into new markets and classes like perfume, which launched in March 2024.

In October 2023, following the departure of Jay Sammons, who had led the Carlyle Group’s client, media and retail division within the US, the non-public fairness agency determined to “deemphasise” that a part of its portfolio as a “go ahead funding sector,” based on an inside memo seen by Reuters. Sammons had been a key confidante and advocate for Renfrew, having been the one to steer the acquisition. Sammons declined to remark.

The Path Forward

In her Could 6 e-mail to consultants, Renfrew mentioned impartial contractors would proceed to be part of the brand new Beautycounter. However she additionally mentioned all facets of the neighborhood and gross sales construction, together with earnings and job titles, are being reassessed. In line with a person aware of the matter, Renfrew has been serving to consultants discover work with Arbonne, a rival MLM, to help their incomes whereas Beautycounter is out of motion.

There aren’t any straightforward decisions. If Beautycounter doubles down on wholesale and its personal web site and shops, it seals its destiny as simply one other magnificence model jostling for customers’ consideration. If it sticks with the direct promoting mannequin, it nonetheless has to deal with the issue of churn and the fixed hunt for brand spanking new clients and consultants.

The corporate may look to newer, less-saturated markets, too. Advocates could possibly be switched from quasi-employees to quasi-influencers, and generate a fee by giving their followers a particular code, slightly than ordering inventory on their behalf.

Allen mentioned she’s nonetheless a fan of the model, although purely as a buyer. A cleanser stays a favorite. However she mentioned profitable again consultants might be troublesome.

“Numerous folks that I do know who was once very excessive up in Beautycounter have gone to a different MLM firm and the issues they publish are the identical as what they posted about Beautycounter… ‘that is nice! I’ve by no means had a product work like this!’” Allen mentioned.

Signal as much as The Enterprise of Magnificence e-newsletter, your complimentary, must-read supply for the day’s most vital magnificence and wellness information and evaluation.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here