For one govt, the clearest signal that Neutrogena had misplaced its method got here when their daughter began shopping for CeraVe facewash and moisturiser. The household had cabinets stocked with Neutrogena merchandise. However the 20-year-old needed the model she noticed on TikTok, stated the worker who has since left the corporate.
Kenvue Inc., which owns Neutrogena and Aveeno, has seen its skincare market share plummet to lower than 14 % in 2023 from 23 % in 2019 — when it was the largest within the US, in accordance with retail knowledge from researcher Circana.
Neutrogena is lacking out on what’s now a $42 billion US magnificence market as a result of it retreated exactly when rivals went all in. What had as soon as been a nimble, revolutionary firm, turned slow-moving and cautious, in accordance with 4 former staff who weren’t authorised to talk publicly on the matter.
Confronted with pandemic-induced ingredient shortages, the model centered on getting core gadgets on cabinets and discontinued some prospects’ favorite lotions and cleansers. Neutrogena pulled again on promoting and innovation, an individual conversant in the enterprise stated. As prospects flocked to TikTok to debate all issues skincare associated, the model was gradual to observe them.
Kenvue attributes a lot of Neutrogena’s troubles to fallout from the pandemic. The corporate adjusted its methods to handle adjustments in shopper habits and navigate provide chain constraints, a spokesperson for the corporate stated in an electronic mail. The spokesperson added that funding in advertising and marketing was constant by the pandemic and that Neutrogena has launched greater than 100 new merchandise within the final 5 years.
“I neglect about them, I’ve to confess. They’re not prime of thoughts,” stated Patricia Oyetakin, a dermatologist based mostly close to Atlanta. 9 occasions out of 10, she says, her sufferers attain for CeraVe or La Roche-Posay. “What makes [Neutrogena] totally different? They’re a superb model, however I’m undecided why.” Neutrogena misplaced the title of dermatologists’ No. 1 beneficial skincare model in late 2021; L’Oréal SA’s CeraVe shortly stepped in to take it.
A turnaround plan introduced final yr that appears so much like what opponents have put in place years in the past hasn’t yielded any concrete outcomes. Pores and skin well being and wonder natural gross sales slumped 4.5 % within the newest quarter, the corporate stated Tuesday. That marks the third straight quarter of such declines.
Mimicking the playbook of rivals isn’t a foul concept. However that’s the minimal wanted simply to maintain from falling additional behind, stated Piper Sandler analyst Korinne Wolfmeyer.
For skeptical buyers — to not point out fickle Gen-Z shoppers who’ve moved on to different manufacturers — it will not be sufficient to win.
Falling Off the Radar
Neutrogena, based in 1930 beneath the identify Natone, turned a status magnificence model in America on its California vibe and dermatologists’ suggestions.
When Johnson & Johnson purchased Neutrogena in 1994 for nearly $1 billion, the healthcare large gave the model better distribution and deeper pockets for science-centric promoting. The road of merchandise expanded over time to incorporate not simply cleaning soap, however sunscreens, wrinkle cream, zits remedies and lip gloss — fuelling gross sales features and garnering a cult-like following amongst younger ladies. A fresh-faced Jennifer Garner appeared in Neutrogena’s TV spots.
For some time, Neutrogena continued to really feel like an unbiased, family-run model that was separate from its mum or dad’s company affect, stated the previous staff. Southwest-inspired people artwork from Lloyd Cotsen — Neutrogena’s multimillionaire president — hung all through its Los Angeles workplace, and a human-sized stuffed cow named Elsie greeted employees and guests alike inside the doorway.
However as J&J introduced Neutrogena extra into the company fold, former staff stated it began to lose its method. As typically occurs in acquisitions, the model’s devoted gross sales staff was tapped to promote merchandise throughout the mum or dad firm’s portfolio. Neutrogena started to fall off the radar of shoppers — and physicians — amid rising competitors.
One of many product strains that traditionally distinguished Neutrogena from rivals was solar safety. The model’s Helioplex sunscreens had robust assist amongst dermatologists centered on pores and skin most cancers prevention, one of many staff stated. However as shopper issues arose over the security of chemical-based sunscreens, CeraVe swooped in with a hydrating mineral-based sunscreen in 2019 that grabbed important shopper consideration. Whereas Neutrogena had its personal mineral sunscreen beneath the Sheer Zinc label on the time, some dermatologists stated it was misplaced within the noise.
Neutrogena’s downfall “began with that mineral sunscreen,” stated Amy Brodsky, a dermatologist based mostly in Rockford, Illinois, who has labored with CeraVe on a marketing campaign. “CeraVe sort of beat them to the punch.”
L’Oréal jumped on the chance to push its method into dermatologists’ workplaces. Oyetakin says she’s on a texting foundation along with her CeraVe gross sales rep, who comes as soon as a month to drop off samples, whereas Neutrogena’s rep has solely visited as soon as this yr.
The dermatologist says she used to contemplate the model a significant participant, however the skincare panorama started to shift in late 2020. Customers and influencers caught at house on their telephones largely formed the dialog on social media. “CeraVe truthfully or simply L’Oréal generally seized that chance early and so they’ve held onto it tightly,” she stated.
CeraVe started advertising and marketing its merchandise on TikTok in 2020. That yr it climbed its solution to teen women’ prime skincare model, the place it’s now been ever since, in accordance with Piper Sandler. CeraVe cornered practically 29 % of skincare gross sales {dollars} throughout the nation in 2023.
Neutrogena, which didn’t embrace TikTok till 2021, has slipped within the rankings, edged out by not simply CeraVe but in addition The Odd, La Roche-Posay, Cetaphil and Glow Recipe.
Neutrogena additionally pulled again on extra conventional promoting. The model spent simply $51 million on nationwide TV adverts in 2022, lower than half of what it spent in 2020, knowledge from iSpotTV.com reveals. And throughout manufacturers, Kenvue spent $71 million much less on analysis and improvement in 2020 than it did the yr prior. It took three years for R&D spending to surpass its pre-pandemic stage.
In the meantime, opponents ramped up their very own new launches. Rival E.l.f. Magnificence, famous Piper Sandler’s Wolfmeyer, appears to introduce one thing new each few weeks, which is essential to staying prime of thoughts amongst teenagers.
“It’s a brand new concept to be this launch heavy,” she stated.
Within the midst of Neutrogena shedding each thoughts and market share, J&J, which additionally owns Listerine and Tylenol, spun off the consumer-side of its enterprise as Kenvue in an preliminary public providing final Could.
Kenvue’s inventory has dropped about 27 % since then, partly because of lagging gross sales in pores and skin well being and wonder, which makes up about 28 % of the enterprise. Even because the skincare business grew gross sales items by 3.6 % final yr, in accordance with Circana knowledge, gross sales volumes of Kenvue’s manufacturers fell 4.8 % in 2023.
“Neutrogena US is a major a part of the enterprise. It’s a high-margin enterprise,” stated RBC analyst Nik Modi. “It’s an enormous deal for buyers.”
Too Little, Too Late?
Turning round Kenvue’s skincare enterprise — and particularly the Neutrogena model — now rests on the shoulders of Jan Meurer, who was promoted to group president of North America from chief development officer on Jan. 1. To this point, the plan he’s tasked with executing has left buyers unimpressed.
In a survey of about 60 shareholders, greater than half stated they have been sceptical or not assured that administration can flip round its skincare enterprise because of a scarcity of innovation and rising competitors, Modi stated in a be aware printed in February.
The corporate says it’s focussed on making retail shows extra seen and simpler to buy, and redesigning packaging to higher spotlight product advantages. Neutrogena is focusing on dermatologists with samples and scientific analysis. Final October, it launched a brand new line of “Hydro Increase” water lotions. All crucial steps, however they haven’t precisely thrust the ailing model again into the highlight.
Like its opponents, Neutrogena has enlisted “dermfluencers” and celebs to stump for it. The model can be making an attempt to construct a bridge to Gen-Z in a latest marketing campaign that includes each Garner, now 52, and 21-year-old actress Jenna Ortega.
Kenvue says it would take till the second half of this yr, and into 2025, to right its errors — and for gross sales to choose up.
“Stabilising this enterprise is a key precedence for us,” chief govt officer Thibaut Mongon instructed buyers on the corporate’s first-quarter earnings name. “We aren’t the place we wish to be when it comes to market-share. The restoration will take time and won’t be linear.”
Internally, Meurer is making adjustments. In April, the corporate closed the model’s California headquarters, shedding workers amid a transfer to New Jersey. In additional restructuring, Kenvue is dismissing 51 staff from its Skillman, New Jersey, workplace this spring in preparation for a transfer to a brand new 290,000-square foot headquarters 37 miles north in Summit. And the corporate introduced Tuesday that it’s chopping about 4 % of its world workforce. Neutrogena is recruiting somebody to steer its healthcare skilled advertising and marketing, and assist give you “science that sells.”
Amongst sure shoppers, it nonetheless could also be a tough promote.
Thirty-two-year previous Alessa Kiyohiro in San Francisco has some 1 million followers throughout TikTok and Instagram who tune in for her suggestions on skincare and wonder merchandise. She stated she was a fan of Neutrogena’s merchandise in her teenagers however has by no means talked about them on her channels.
“Neutrogena is just like the one model that I haven’t actually gone again to attempt to in a very long time.”
By Leslie Patton
Signal as much as The Enterprise of Magnificence e-newsletter, your complimentary, must-read supply for the day’s most essential magnificence and wellness information and evaluation.
